When reviewing and/or post-processing photos I judge the particular characteristics in each image that appeal to me. I have no one else to please.
However, I often think that I may not be ruthless enough in the editing stage. I sometimes become attached to my photos–the good and the not-so-good. This may partly come from the fact being a photography aficionado I don’t shoot as much as say a photo professional, so photo trips are special or often dual purpose.
I accept to be able to take good photographs you need to know what a good photo looks like in the first place. Achieving this comes from instruction, practice and objectively viewing the work of others. There are also the obvious issues of natural talent and opportunities, which I won’t get into here. We learn what works and what doesn’t.
Photography is about being both a technician and an artist. In my own development, I currently feel strongest at being a technician and weakest as an artist. Learning to become a better artist is partly dependent upon that natural talent I spoke of earlier, but I believe anyones artistic abilities can be broadened or enhanced with artistic exposure and feedback. Sometimes it’s also a matter of unlearning some of what you thought you knew.
Everyone can benefit by having their work objectively critiqued. Posting photos is one way to expose yourself to this feedback–just as leaving comments is one way to provide constructive feedback to others who may seek it.
While a “great photo” comment is “nice” and appreciated it often gives very little detail. I’ll most often learn nothing from such a comment except that someone liked my photo for some unstated reason. The same goes when someone comments they don’t care for the photo–what don’t you care for?
My treasure is when someone gives an excellent commentary with suggestions for improvement or an explanation about what exactly appeals or doesn’t appeal to them. I read these carefully and weigh them against my own ideas and concepts. I learn from your thoughts!
Hey, I’m guilty of leaving “nice photo” comments. I know better and I should do better but sometimes I don’t.
I also often say what I like about a photo–the bright colors, the sharp contrast or the interesting composition but don’t speak up when I “don’t get” a photo. By avoiding these conversations perhaps I’m also missing a chance to learn.
So, please feel free to be the judge of my photos and leave comments/feedback explaining what you do or don’t like about them. I’ll appreciate each one.
Your comments–my treasures!