Positive vs. negative

//Positive vs. negative

Since she first joined our family, Maggie has been a puller. As a rescue, she seems to always be in a hurry to get somewhere and it’s often somewhere she shouldn’t be. As she grew into her full, leggy 65-70 pounds, this became a problem too great for the control ability of a standard dog collar and leash. It wasn’t long before we purchased her first no-pull harness.

This first harness was designed for dogs to step into it.  The leash connected to a ring on her back, just behind her shoulders. When she pulled, the ring would tighten two straps that ran behind and under her front legs thus applying pressure to her chest, encouraging her to not pull. It was basically giving her feedback that pulling was something she shouldn’t be doing. This harness worked well for a while but over time Maggie learned to ignore this negative feedback and would continue pulling using her full strength. Walking her through a complex environment became stressful for her and me.

With the onset of Maggie’s anxiety disorder she began to react strongly and sometimes aggressively toward other dogs when she was on the leash. Maggie is powerful, stubborn and determined.  Not an easy combination to manage on a walk. She pulled so often and so strongly that Bonnie could not walk her even when using the no-pull harness.

Needless to say, I’ve been doing a lot of Internet searches these days for Maggie.  One such search led me to a totally different design of harness and philosophy for preventing dogs from pulling…the Walk Your Dog With Love (WYDWL) harness which Maggie is modeling in the above picture.  There is only one strap which goes around, under and behind her front legs. Then a single strap attaches above her shoulders to this body band that loops to the front of her chest. It is this front chest strap which has the ring attachment point for a leash.

Putting the WYDWL harness on Maggie was very simple. The harness goes over her head with the label on the outside and the ring to the front. Then the strap goes behind her front legs and clicks into the buckle on the other side…no stepping into required. Even Maggie seems to appreciate that.

I was a bit skeptical when I placed an order for this harness. It looks like a little bit of nothing and knowing the power of Maggie I had my doubts it could control her.  Boy was I wrong. The results have been remarkable.  With the leash attachment being in front, the harness provides positive guidance of where we want her to go and it has changed her reaction entirely — no pulling!  She also seems calmer and if she starts to relapse into an aggressive stance towards another dog it’s just a matter of a small tug to turn her aside and regain her attention. It works so well we’ve ordered a second harness to keep in the truck as a back-up.

What use to be an apprehensive experience for me, walking Maggie around an RV Park, has now become something I enjoy again.  I’m less stressed which I’m sure is making her less stressed.


By | 2017-12-21T15:36:39+00:00 March 28th, 2017|Opinion & Reviews|4 Comments

About the Author:


  1. Monte Stevens 29 Mar ’17 at 2:57 pm - Reply

    Wow! That is kool. Lots of changes going on for you three. Hope this solves

    • E. Brooks Moore 30 Mar ’17 at 10:08 am - Reply

      Yeah, having to deal with these issues revolving around Maggie have been a learning experience for us all. I’m still hopeful we can find solutions that make it less stressful for all of us again. 🙂

  2. Mark 3 Apr ’17 at 7:26 pm - Reply

    I am still trying to picture how that works vs. a regular harness, Maggie can you spit around a little??
    Our malamute Willow is a natural puller of course. Built into their genes probably. Normally she isn’t too bad except when she’s really excited to go for a walk, or she feels she really has to do her business down at the end of the block instead of right in our yard.

    • E. Brooks Moore 3 Apr ’17 at 7:51 pm - Reply

      Mark, there’s a bit of magic in this harness I can’t identify but what a difference it’s made in walking Maggie. With the old harness she would drop low into a wide legged pulling stance and it was then just a matter of having the strength to stop her. With this one as soon as she begins to pull or head in a direction you don’t want her to go a light tug will immediately turn/guide her. There was a “what-the-heck” look on her face the first few times but I’ve notice now she’s trying her tricks less and less because she’s learning there’s no longer any pay-off. There are video’s on the WYDWL web sites. I also like how this harness isn’t bulky or doesn’t in any way choke or constrict movement. As you can tell, I’m sold on this one and she seems to like it as well. 🙂

Leave A Comment